verifying-crypto-with-lean/check-book.sh
mrwulf 311f60d4d0 move 7: the book's button — check-book.sh + check-book.py
The only source of 'ALL GREEN' for this repository. Rebuilds the PDF,
then verifies 93 countable claims printed in the book against reality
measured at run time:

- source hygiene: inputs<->files both directions, contiguous ch01..ch14,
  every chapter (and the interlude) ends on its checkpoint, per-chapter
  exercise count == solution count with hand-typed numbering N.1..N.k
- built PDF: >=100 pages, zero unresolved references, any page-count
  claim in prose must equal pdfinfo
- internal congruence: chapter-count words in README/ch01 vs measured N
  ('spent twelve chapters' in ch13 is checked as a positional count, not
  grepped as stale — the spelling-vs-property lesson, applied to the
  checker itself); week-plan heading == max table row; the
  discussion-exercise roster parsed from prose == measured set; the
  SLH-DSA arithmetic recomputed from scratch (digest split 21/7/2, sig
  7856, fixed 254, per-layer max 510 by brute force, worst 3824,
  checksum digit examples) and each value required present in ch13
- cross-repo congruence: 19 leaves derived by property (six-digit
  filenames + index fields — the entries/ glob counts 25); every
  nineteen/19 claim in prose parsed and compared; leaves 13-16 subjects
  + 44 certs; leaves 12/17 = 61; leaves 0-11 = 16; leaf 18 = 11 certs,
  apex cone kernel-3+5 oracles, ht cone f,h,t_l, four kernel-3-only
  plumbing certs, all cones exact; first dual-signed head at size 14;
  final head size == leaf count; ch13 parameter card == the const-generic
  arguments parsed out of the extracted Funs.lean; ch07's 71-digit Q ==
  P25519.lean digit for digit

Fails closed: a missing sibling repo is a FAILURE, not a skip;
BOOK_LOCAL_ONLY=1 skips cross-repo loudly and never prints ALL GREEN.
--selftest mutates copies of the sources seven ways (count drift,
deleted solution, one Q digit, leaf-count drift, arithmetic drift,
stray box after a checkpoint, plan/heading divergence) and requires each
to be caught BY ITS OWN CHECK, plus an unmutated control that must pass.

Full run: ALL GREEN (93 checks). Selftest: 8/8.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-08 14:16:30 +02:00

111 lines
5 KiB
Bash
Executable file

#!/usr/bin/env bash
# check-book.sh — THE button for verifying-crypto-with-lean.
#
# This script is the only source of the words "ALL GREEN" for this
# repository. It rebuilds the book from the committed sources and then
# verifies that every countable claim printed in the book matches reality
# measured at run time: chapter counts, the week plan, exercise/solution
# pairing, the recomputed SLH-DSA arithmetic, the transparency log's leaf
# and certificate counts, the first dual-signed head, the extracted
# parameter card, and the 71-digit Q — digit for digit.
#
# Phases
# 0 source hygiene (check-book.py)
# 1 build (tectonic via build.sh; fails on TeX errors)
# 1b built-PDF claims (pages, unresolved refs, page-count claims)
# 2 internal congruence (counts and arithmetic inside the book)
# 3 cross-repo congruence (log + fips205 + P25519 siblings)
#
# Environment
# BOOK_LOCAL_ONLY=1 skip phase 3; verdict is downgraded, never ALL GREEN
# ESTATE_ROOT parent dir of the sibling repos (default: ../)
# LTL_DIR / FIPS205_DIR / P25519_FILE override individual siblings
#
# Modes
# ./check-book.sh full run
# ./check-book.sh --selftest adversarial self-test: mutates copies of the
# sources and asserts the button turns RED
set -euo pipefail
cd "$(dirname "$0")"
HERE="$(pwd)"
selftest() {
echo "=== SELFTEST: the button must go red for the right reasons ==="
command -v python3 >/dev/null || { echo "python3 required"; exit 1; }
# the mutated copy keeps the REAL sibling repos: only the book is mutated,
# so a red verdict proves the mutation was caught, not that a repo was lost
local ESTATE; ESTATE="${ESTATE_ROOT:-$(dirname "$HERE")}"
local tmp out pass=0 fail=0
run_copy() {
tmp="$(mktemp -d)"; mkdir -p "$tmp/chapters"
cp main.tex README.md "$tmp/"; cp chapters/*.tex "$tmp/chapters/"
}
run_mutated() { # $1 description, $2 mutation cmd, $3 expected FAIL substring
run_copy
( cd "$tmp" && eval "$2" )
out="$(SKIP_BUILD=1 ESTATE_ROOT="$ESTATE" python3 "$HERE/check-book.py" "$tmp" 2>&1)" \
&& { echo " FAIL mutation NOT caught: $1"; fail=$((fail+1)); rm -rf "$tmp"; return; }
if echo "$out" | grep -q "FAIL.*$3"; then
echo " ok caught for the right reason: $1"; pass=$((pass+1))
else
echo " FAIL red, but not on the expected check ('$3'): $1"; fail=$((fail+1))
echo "$out" | grep " FAIL" | head -3
fi
rm -rf "$tmp"
}
# control: the unmutated copy must pass (proves the harness can go green)
run_copy
if SKIP_BUILD=1 ESTATE_ROOT="$ESTATE" python3 "$HERE/check-book.py" "$tmp" >/dev/null 2>&1; then
echo " ok control: unmutated copy passes"; pass=$((pass+1))
else
echo " FAIL control: unmutated copy should pass but is red"; fail=$((fail+1))
SKIP_BUILD=1 ESTATE_ROOT="$ESTATE" python3 "$HERE/check-book.py" "$tmp" | grep FAIL || true
fi
rm -rf "$tmp"
run_mutated "chapter-count claim drifts (fourteen -> thirteen)" \
"sed -i 's/fourteen chapters/thirteen chapters/' README.md" \
"README chapter count"
run_mutated "a solution deleted (ch13 solhead 13.6 dropped)" \
"sed -i 's/\\\\solhead{13.6}/% gone/' chapters/ch13-second-summit.tex" \
"ch13: exercises == solutions"
run_mutated "one digit of the 71-digit Q changed in ch07" \
"sed -i 's/740582127325613583022312264370627886761/740582127325613583022312264370627886762/' chapters/ch07-primality-certificates.tex" \
"printed Q == repository"
run_mutated "leaf-count claim drifts (nineteen leaves -> twenty)" \
"sed -i \"s/log's nineteen leaves/log's twenty leaves/\" chapters/ch14-attestation-protocol.tex" \
"ch14 'nineteen leaves'"
run_mutated "worst-case arithmetic drifts (3,824 -> 3,689)" \
"sed -i 's/3{,}824/3{,}689/' chapters/ch13-second-summit.tex" \
"ch13 prints worst total"
run_mutated "a chapter stops ending on its checkpoint" \
"printf '\n\\\\begin{aha}\nstray box after the checkpoint\n\\\\end{aha}\n' >> chapters/ch05-numbers-and-automation.tex" \
"ch05.*last environment is checkpoint"
run_mutated "week plan and heading diverge (heading says fifteen)" \
"sed -i 's/A fourteen-week plan/A fifteen-week plan/' main.tex" \
"week-plan heading"
echo
if [ "$fail" -gt 0 ]; then
echo "SELFTEST RED: $fail defect(s) in the button itself"; exit 1
fi
echo "SELFTEST GREEN: $pass/$pass (control + 7 mutations, each caught on its own check)"
exit 0
}
[ "${1:-}" = "--selftest" ] && selftest
echo "=== Phase 1: build ==="
./build.sh
command -v pdfinfo >/dev/null && command -v pdftotext >/dev/null || {
echo "FAIL: poppler-utils (pdfinfo/pdftotext) required"; exit 1; }
python3 "$HERE/check-book.py" "$HERE"
echo
if [ "${BOOK_LOCAL_ONLY:-0}" = "1" ]; then
echo "VERDICT: build green + local claims green; cross-repo NOT verified."
else
echo "ALL GREEN — the book builds and every countable claim matches"
echo "measured reality (sources, PDF, transparency log, extracted code)."
fi