ESTATE.md was still the 2026-07-22 snapshot (13 leaves, v0.9, 'SLH-DSA
NOT in the log'); llms.txt still said thirteen leaves, 23 pages, and
linked the retired /paper/v0.x routes; README repeated the stdlib-only
verify.py trap the site just fixed; evidence/README called the July
capture's 16/16 attestations 'definitive' and its 8-leaf state current.
All brought to truth. Entry numbering standardized on 0-based leaf
index with 'the thirteenth entry' as the ordinal gloss (docs, lab
manual, security note, mirror README template). Operator-machine path
removed from provider/README.
Nine parallel readers audited every doc against measured ground truth; every
finding was re-verified against the file before any edit, and the sweep fixed
by PROPERTY, not by flag — wording the readers caught in one repo was hunted
in all siblings (the two-button README sentence existed in all four forks,
not the three flagged; likewise the cone-overclaim in TRUSTED-BASE item 1).
This repo: see the diff. Records were not rewritten; clarifications are
dated. Doc-only except where noted in the estate summary; every gated doc
change was followed by a green button run.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The deployed consistency verifier implemented the RFC 9162 2.1.4.2
bit-navigation loop but its final return checked only the two
reconstructed roots, omitting the terminal condition that the new-size
navigation counter reach zero. That condition couples the consumed proof
length to the claimed tree sizes; without it, a valid proof for one
transition verifies under a lied (power-of-two) old size. Flagship: a
valid 2->3 proof is accepted under the false claim 1->3 with the size-2
root.
Fix: add `and sn == 0` to the final return.
This is the corpus's Known Gap 14 (3,867 deployed-accepts-only cases in a
pinned 73,573-case family, recorded in public log entry 13). It was
found by the project's own differential harness; a post-appeal review
round added a faithful RFC oracle as a third comparison, which showed
the deployed verifier — not the mechanized model — was the one deviating
from RFC 9162, and traced it to the missing terminal check.
Scope: verify_consistency's only production caller is the consumer-side
pin store, reached only behind a verified head signature. Generation is
RFC-correct and unaffected; the live provider service does not run this
verifier; the published standalone verify.py has no consistency verifier.
An empirical search found 0 realizable pin-advance poisons against an
honestly pinned consumer, consistent with Known Gap 14's non-claim.
Verification:
- New fail-first three-way regression test
test_consistency_lied_size_three_way_agreement (deployed / recursive
ConsRec model / independent faithful RFC 9162 transliteration) over the
honest AND lied-size families; fails pre-fix, passes post-fix.
- Historical differential tests (164,479 inclusion; 164,224 consistency)
unchanged — the fix rejects nothing honest.
- Full suite: 145 passed, 0 failed.
Public log entry 13, the attested accumulator commit, and the IACR
submission PDF are all unchanged. Vulnerable state tagged
vulnerable/sn0-consistency-fd2f6ba. See
docs/security-2026-07-23-consistency-terminal-check.md.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Audit question: is the documentation coherent, and is the app portable
to a fresh machine (macOS) with proper isolation? Findings and fixes:
- README never mentioned the cockpit/deck/lab manual (three rounds of UI
evolution invisible at the front door). Added: human-surface section
with the one command, expanded Install (editable-from-clone is the
supported mode — repo files are part of the product; zero-install
PYTHONPATH=src alternative; fresh-machine skip behavior), macOS
openssl/LibreSSL Ed25519 prerequisite with a one-line self-check,
wallet commands in the command list.
- The lab manual violated the repo's own macOS law (AGENTS.md): GNU
sha256sum -> shasum -a 256; GNU sed -i -> portable python3 -c
one-liner (executed and output-matched before shipping: entry 0 hash
mismatch, BROKEN, exit 1).
- Fresh-clone bootstrap was actually tested end to end in a scratch
clone: zero-install suite 130 passed / 0 failed / 14 skipped after
fixing the one unguarded test (test_ledger_is_hash_chained now skips
like its siblings when the dogfood binary is absent - capability gap,
not failure); venv + pip install -e . -> pacta console script serves
bridge/deck/manual/sample-prefill/drift-tripwire with no PYTHONPATH.
- PYTHONPATH incantations simplified: cockpit needs src only (provider
never imported by src/pacta); manual + cockpit.md updated.
- threat-model.md: cockpit attack-surface note (no mutating routes,
no auth because nothing to operate, localhost-only disclosure risk,
probe-only network I/O, fake-cockpit = host-compromise boundary).
- products.md: cockpit named as the shared human surface of all four
profiles. AGENTS.md: doc-portability law + the cockpit's three laws
added to the standing guidance.
Suite 144 green here; 130/0/14 on a bare clone.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Operator asked for a real big fat user manual: read on one monitor with
the deck on the other, worked like a lab from beginning to end, with
highest didactical skill — the goal being to educate ONE person in ALL
roles, as if to BECOME each role. Shipped as a full course:
- docs/warden-lab-manual.md (canonical, ~7100 words): 8 sessions +
capstone. Fixed didactic ritual per role-session: why the role exists
-> the mind of the role -> concepts -> LAB (numbered machine exercises
with checkpoint rails) -> never-list with whys + thought experiment ->
handoff artifact -> self-test -> recap card. Notation: do / checkpoint
/ write / optional. Capstone 'incident day': one incident walked
through all six chairs producing seven written artifacts; graduation
session maps the path to a real wallet; Appendix A command reference
by chair, Appendix B full self-test answers.
- Session 4's tamper drill: copy the demo wallet, flip one character of
ledger history, watch verify-ledger AND a second cockpit catch it.
Every checkpoint in the manual was executed by the author before
commit: status fields, intact-chain exit 0, tampered-chain 'entry 0:
hash mismatch / BROKEN' exit 1, CUSTODY EVIDENCE BROKEN banner.
- src/pacta/mdlite.py: deliberately small stdlib Markdown renderer
(headings/anchors+TOC, bold/italic/code with placeholder stashing,
fences, lists, quotes, tables, links); tested against the real manual
for zero artifact leaks.
- /manual route with syllabus TOC; manual typography (checkpoint boxes,
session borders); nav tab, deck wizard cross-link, cli hint.
Suite 142 -> 144 green; read-only sweep covers /manual.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Operator asked for a tmux-type panes grid in the browser (one pane per
role, all acting in parallel, like real life) with a wizard on the right
that takes a newcomer by the hand through every role's actions, each
instruction camouflaged in that role's color.
- /deck: CSS-grid of six live panes (2-col, 3-col on wide screens),
one per station, each an iframe onto /station/<id>?pane=1. tmux
controls per pane: reload, single-pane zoom, open-full. Narrow
screens: wizard first, panes stacked.
- pane mode (?pane=1): chrome-stripped shell (no h1/banner/nav), same
station content, READ-ONLY label kept; an 8-line shim re-carries
pane=1 on every same-origin link and form submit, so probes, incident
browsing, and inspect verdicts all happen inside the pane.
- the wizard: a 10-step guided first watch across all six roles on the
live demo wallet. Each step card wears the role's hue with a 'YOU ARE
THE <ROLE>' chip, the matching pane glows, and every step states what
success looks like + what was just learned. Step remembered per
session (sessionStorage).
- /inspect?sample=1 pre-fills examples/wallet-evidence so the
cryptographer step verifies (then deliberately breaks) real evidence.
- verified in a real browser: step navigation moves the glow, panes
load their stations, Probe-now inside the pane probed live inside the
pane (log head tree_size 13), sample flow prefilled the key in-pane.
Suite 139 -> 142 green. Read-only guarantee unchanged; byte sweep
covers /deck and pane routes.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Operator verdict on round two: better, but 'still no coherent
application'. The cockpit must provide everything a human crew would
need if no AI were around — as distinct roles that cooperate through
handoffs and never melt into each other. This rebuilds the IA as a
bridge with six stations over shared instruments, in the control-room
tradition (overview -> station -> instrument -> raw files/CLI), with
maker-checker separation of duties encoded in the UI itself.
- / is now the Bridge: whole-system verdict strip, six crew cards with
live data, and the dispatch (andon) board 'if this happens, who acts'
- /station/{proposer,quorum,operator,cryptographer,architect,newcomer}:
each console has a fixed anatomy: Mission -> Duties (every duty a
runnable, verified-real CLI command - the no-AI drill) -> embedded
live instruments -> 'This station never...' (separation of duties) ->
Handoffs (receives/delivers)
- Operator gets a real liveness board: on-demand parallel probes (HTTP
GET on log head/paper/blog/mirror with observed facts + latency; git
HEAD/cleanliness on all 9 local repos). Never probes on ordinary page
loads. Verified live: caught this very repo as 'alive, dirty' while
building it, and confirmed log 13/3488a2d0 + paper 7f140356
- Architect gets the live drift tripwire (ESTATE.md vs estate view)
- modularized per the standing separation-of-concerns order:
uikit.py (primitives+style), stations.py (role model, pure),
liveness.py (probes), walletui.py (collectors, instruments, routes)
- crew law test-enforced: bridge crew+dispatch, per-station role
contract, station distinctness (signature phrases must not bleed
across roles), explicit-probe semantics; read-only byte sweep now
covers all 13 routes incl. the probe route
- narrow-viewport fix: breakany for unbreakable paths in headings
Suite 135 -> 139 green. Read-only guarantee unchanged: no mutating
routes; every custody act is a printed command, never a button.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Operator verdict on the first cockpit: unusable, jargon-walled. The
evidence layer was honest but the presentation assumed the reader
already lived inside warden's head. This rebuilds the presentation
layer around a testable UX contract, additive to the design law:
- every page: verdict IN WORDS first (CUSTODY HEALTHY / CUSTODY FROZEN
(LATCHED) / CUSTODY EVIDENCE BROKEN), then evidence, then provenance
- every page: plain-language lead saying what the page answers
- every panel: 'How to read this panel' expander interpreting every
column and pill; jargon carries a ? linking to the glossary
- new /guide view: what warden is, how to read any page, color code,
five-minute tour, 12-term glossary, honest 'what this cockpit cannot
tell you'
- navigation: two-line tabs stating the question each view answers,
present on every page; /estate gets a back-to-cockpit chip
- explained empty states (incidents: 'empty is the good state')
- narrow-viewport fix: tables/pre scroll in their own containers
- estate fact chip updated 130->135 green (both renderings)
UX contract is test-enforced (guide terms, lead+nav+explainers on every
view, empty states); read-only byte-guarantee sweep now covers /guide.
Verified by looking: served --demo, walked all six views in a browser.
Suite 131 -> 135 green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The operator ran the documented command and hit the fail-fast (no
wallet exists on a fresh machine) — correct behavior, useless
instruction. seal_demo_wallet() now seals a throwaway DEMO wallet
(fake shell-stub members, DEMO-labeled fields, temp dir named
warden-DEMO-*, sample incident/refusal/airgap so every view has
content); 'pacta wallet cockpit --demo' serves it. Exactly one of
--wallet/--demo required. Verified by running the literal command:
all five views 200, demo quorum renders. Suite 130 -> 131.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Operator questions answered in code: (1) the estate map now lives IN the
cockpit too — /estate serves the interactive map (lanes, typed edges,
loops, clickable dossiers) to the same human audience the cockpit
serves; ESTATE.md remains the canonical committed version (renders on
GitHub, reachable by agents via llms.txt, needs no running process), and
a name-level sync test guards drift between the two renderings — the
published_assets lesson applied preemptively. (2) 'What is RUNNING?' is
now answered everywhere: an operations strip on the map (ALWAYS ON:
caddy + the LTL read-only container + Forgejo with its single 03:00
mirror cron, all droplet; ON-DEMAND: append/publish/sign ceremonies,
cockpit, MCP, operator machine only; NOT RUNNING: warden — prototype,
no deployed instance, no funds watched; everything else: static files
or external parties), a per-entity Runtime line in every dossier, and a
verified What-is-running table in ESTATE.md (container commands, :ro
mounts and read_only:true on the LTL service, and the crontab checked
on the droplet 2026-07-20, not recalled).
Suite 128 -> 130 (estate route + drift guard). Local-only as before:
nothing deployed, live estate untouched.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Operator-ordered milestone, built under an explicit no-risk constraint
while the paper application is in flight: strictly ADDITIVE (one new
module + one CLI subcommand; zero changes to wallet semantics, the
public site, or anything the paper describes), LOCAL-ONLY (never
deployed; binds 127.0.0.1), and READ-ONLY in v1 (human approve/deny is
deliberately deferred — that is a custody-semantics change belonging to
a separately reviewed milestone).
New: src/pacta/walletui.py — four views over an existing wallet:
- Posture: latch state, ledger head with FULL hash-chain
re-verification, pinned quorum members, spending policy verbatim.
- Signature queue: airgap outbox/inbox, observed never operated.
- Incidents & refusals: verbatim records, newest first.
- Receipt inspector: paste attestation + receipt + log key; verdict,
per-signature results, and diagnostics come verbatim from
transparency.verify_receipt — the deployed verifier itself, reused
not reimplemented.
Design law, stated in the module and enforced by tests: THE COCKPIT
RENDERS EVIDENCE, IT NEVER ASSERTS IT. Every panel recomputes at
request time and carries a provenance line (function + timestamp);
anything unverifiable renders a loud FAILED-TO-VERIFY panel — no cached
green, no neutral gray. Panels state what they do NOT prove (e.g.
binary pinning vs source-to-binary correspondence).
CLI: pacta wallet cockpit --wallet DIR [--host --port].
Tests (10 new, suite 118 -> 128 green): recomputed-evidence rendering,
CHAIN BROKEN on tampered ledger, loud failure on collector error,
latched-state rendering, airgap queue states, verbatim incident/refusal
rendering, fail-closed inspector on garbage, real-evidence roundtrip
(skips if example evidence absent), full-sweep BYTE-LEVEL read-only
guarantee (wallet dir hash-identical after all GETs + a POST), and
fail-fast on non-wallet dirs. Rendering additionally verified visually
against a live demo wallet (posture, quorum table, incidents).
Docs: docs/cockpit.md; WALLET.md section; ESTATE.md + llms.txt updated.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Self-contained dark-theme product page: the one idea, the trust-posture
asymmetry, the firewall diagram, the four deployment profiles, and the
non-claims. Also published as an artifact.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
